Dean campaign insider Paul Maslin provides the inside perspective on what happened to Howard Dean. Personally, the "aargh" explanation never did it for me. Interestingly enough, my personal theory--"Atlantic Monthly" conspiracy plot-- holds that the monthly purposefully published the heroic portrayal of Vietnam veteran John Kerry to influence the key liberals that supported Dean before the primaries. As it turns out, the vast amount of campaign contributions for Dean came from Ivy League intellectuals, academics, and students.
While Maslin does not directly disprove my Atlantic Monthly theory, he provides interesting, localized reasons for Dean's terrible performance at the primaries. Maslin's description of "Black Sunday" is riveting:
On Thursday, January 8, the Dean campaign was rocked by the news that NBC was airing a videotape of its candidate, as a guest commentator on a Canadian public-affairs program several years earlier, criticizing the Iowa caucuses. The tape dominated Iowa news coverage through the following weekend, even overshadowing Dean's endorsement by the popular Tom Harkin. Then, that Sunday, January 11, came three negative developments: the state's dominant newspaper, The Des Moines Register, endorsed John Edwards; Dean shouted down a Republican heckler at a campaign event; and, exhausted and unbriefed, Dean was forced to admit, under fire from Al Sharpton, that he had never hired an African-American to a cabinet post during his time as the governor of Vermont.
Our poll that Sunday night, a week before the caucuses, showed the expected results: Dean had now fallen into a virtual three-way tie with Kerry and Gephardt, and Edwards was riding close on our heels. Our favorability rating had plummeted to a new low, just as those of Kerry and Edwards had started to rise, in part because they were liberally borrowing our message of populism and empowerment. I had seen this movie before: after weeks of declining support, Paul Simon had received the Register's endorsement and surged in the final week before the 1988 Iowa caucuses, and had nearly caught Gephardt. I began to think that Edwards might win and Dean might finish third.